Parents, you’ve got questions, we’ve got answers.

Or just as likely, we’ve got questions and you’ve got answers.

Challenge: Open Discussion

Explain Your "Why"

Vote up!
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Email this article

Explain Your Why

My son is (& has always been) a very strong-willed, determined boy. He is kind, he is patient, & he is respectful; but he also very logical, inquisitive, & determined. From a young age, people would comment about how he is a “little lawyer” who could get them to come around & see his side of the debate.

I learned fairly quickly that if I had a good reason for the things that I was asking him to do, he would happily do that. If he saw something as pointless, or if he had a better way of doing things, he would fight for his opinion endlessly.

So instead of turning each day into a power struggle, I reflected on things a bit… The conclusions that I came to are things that I think can be beneficial to any parent/child relationships regardless of the age of the child or their personality type!

I should have well thought out reasons behind my rules.

When I coached gymnastics, we had a rule that the kids always needed to land on their feet or their seat. Why? This was a huge safety issue. Flopping on their bellies or diving head first into the foam pit could cause serious injury. Some coaches got mad at the kids & simply yelled at them to land on their feet or their bottom over & over again, but if I had someone who was purposefully trying to bend the rule, I would take the time to explain it to them...

“If you land on your belly in the foam pit, it is too soft, & your back will bend too far, which could really hurt you. If you land on your head (even in the foam pit), it is not like a swimming pool… you could seriously hurt your neck by doing that. I want you to have fun, & that means that I have to make sure you stay safe.”

Sometimes the reasons behind your rules might be a little less clear (even to you), but typically there is a good reason for the things that I tell my kids…

“You need to be kind to your friends so that they will want to play with you.”

“You need to brush your teeth so that they don’t start to hurt.”

“You need to pick up your toys so that they don’t get stepped on & broken or lost.”

“You need to eat your food now so that your belly doesn’t get hungry while we’re at the park.”

“You need to go to bed so that you aren’t grouchy & tired tomorrow.”

If there’s not a good reason? Then maybe it shouldn’t be a rule...

I should take the time to explain my reasoning to my children.

When my son was upset that he had to go to school 5 days a week, but his little brother only went to preschool 2 days a week, I explained how it is a law that children who go to public school have to go 5 days a week. I explained that we could get in trouble if he missed too many days of school, & I explained that when his brother gets to be his age, he will also be going 5 days a week.

My son had drawn the conclusion that I was choosing to send him 5 days a week. That it was me trying to get a break from him. That I could keep him home, but I just didn’t want to.

This was causing a riff in our mother/son relationship, & I was seeing him act out behaviorally because of this. It was so important for me to be able to explain that I love him, I love spending time with him, & that we are simply following someone else’s rules.

It can be hard to take the time to explain these things to your child especially when it seems like such a minor thing… like putting on shoes before leaving the house...

When we would be heading out the door, & my son needed to put his shoes on... I didn’t always feel like explaining why he had to wear shoes. However, taking the time to logically explain the reasons that we wear shoes (so we don’t step on anything ouchy, so our feet don’t get cold or dirty, because stores require us to wear shoes, etc) prevented future battles over the same issue.

The more that you explain your reasoning, the more it becomes a habit. It is now second nature for me to be thinking through my “why” before asking something of my children. And on the other hand, my children learn the reasons behind the rules so that there doesn’t have to be an explanation every time!

I should be grateful that my children stand up for themselves.

A big reason that I take the time to explain my “why” to my children is that I want them to be able to make decisions for themselves. I won’t always be around to tell them what to do. Giving them a glimpse into my thought processes allows them to learn to make similar decisions for themselves. It allows them to be more independent, gives them leadership skills, & builds confidence.

There are many rules that exist for the well-being & safety of themselves & those around them. I want my children to understand the gravity of those rules, & the risks of breaking them.

However, I don’t want my children to blindly follow the rules. As they grow up, they will be surrounded with more & more people (aside from their parents) that will be telling them what to do. These could be ill-intending peers or adults, & I don’t want my child to simply obey for the sake of obeying.

I want my children to know their own “why” behind their actions so that they can thrive in their own unique way.

*For more on this topic, check out the full Child Behavior collection*


This post comes from the TODAY Parenting Team community, where all members are welcome to post and discuss parenting solutions. Learn more and join us! Because we're all in this together.